Skip to content

A Bad Start: Will Military Defense Counsel Feel Safe to Represent Their Clients?

In a startling turn of events, the Secretary of the Army recently fired the Army’s very first leader of the Army’s new “independent” prosecution office.

The decision, attributed to a decade-old email criticizing the handling of a sexual assault case, raises significant concerns about the purported independence of military attorneys. 

The Background
The saga began in 2013 when then Lieutenant Colonel W. Wells, serving as a supervising military defense attorney, expressed concerns about the fairness of the investigation of a sexual assault allegation in Japan. The Commander responsible for deciding what should happen in that case had his decisions overturned by HQ Army. The result was that a Soldier case, who many thought had insufficient evidence to proceed to trial, was nevertheless referred to trial and the General who had declined to do so was reduced in rank from two stars to one. 

In response, BG Wells, who was then the supervisory military defense counsel, sent an email to his troops to rally them to the seeming unfairness, emphasizing the vital role they played in ensuring fair trials and criticizing the handling of sexual assault allegations. In that email he wrote: “expect no commander to be able to make objective decisions involving [sexual assault] allegations as long [as] Congress and our political masters are dancing by the fire of misleading statistics and one-sided, repetitive misinformation by those with an agenda.” 

The Secretary’s Rationale
Ten years after he sent that email, BG Wells is appointed to be the Army’s top prosecutor, responsible for deciding which military criminal cases have enough evidence to warrant a trial.  However, a former Soldier who had filed complaints against BG Wells in the past forwarded the email he wrote in 2013 to the Secretary of the Army, who promptly fired BG Wells, claiming the email was dismissive of civilian control of the military and “negatively characterized sexual assault response” at the time.

Ominous Response
In response to the Secretary’s decision, LTG Pede, the Army’s former Judge Advocate General, made several good points about how the Secretary’s decision painted an ominous picture for the future of military justice.  See full story here: Guest Post: Chuck Pede asks “Firing the Army chief prosecutor–is this what independence looks like?” – Lawfire (duke.edu)

Dangerous Precedent for Military Defense Counsel
First, he explains that the Secretary’s decision sends a terrible message to uniformed military defense counsel. Using internal defense communications as grounds for relieving one of one’s duty raises legitimate concerns about the fear of reprisal, jeopardizing the zealous, independent representation that every service member deserves.

Doubting The Fairness of Charging Decisions
The whole point of appointing BW Wells and the “Office of Special Trial Counsel” was to take charging decisions out of the hands of commanders, whom Congress believed might make decisions for the wrong reasons.  By relieving BG Wells, the Secretary has created the same concern, but for different reasons. 

Unlawful Command Influence
Finally, the firing of BG Wells creates the appearance that the Secretary is placing her hands on the scales of military justice—that if you “negatively characterize sexual assault,” than you are not fit to serve in prosecutorial roles. 

The Future
The case that prompted Wells’ email a decade ago ultimately validated his concerns, as the Army acknowledged its errors and corrected the reduction in rank for the Commanding General. But the same types of mistakes continue. Soldiers deserve military defense counsel who are not only insulated from risks to their careers if they act zealously in their clients’ behalf but are also SEEN to be insulated.  The Army Secretary’s firing of BG Wells sets that effort back years. 

If you or a loved one are accused or convicted of sexual assault, or any military crime, please reach out to an experienced, independent military defense attorney for a free consultation. 

KML Blue Stars Logo

King Military Law

~~ When Experience Matters Most ~~

COMMENTS

No comment yet, add your voice below!


Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Google Reviews

King Military Law
5.0
Based on 44 reviews
powered by Google
Ariel DifoAriel Difo
02:32 17 Feb 24
I was told by my command and even military lawyers that my separation from the military was inevitable and that there was no way to fight it. I lost all hope was going to accept my separation from the military. But, thanks to the guidance of Mr. King, I was encouraged to fight for my name and was even able to win my board with the help of Mr. King and his Firm. Angela and Kasheta were always there to assist me with any questions or concerns I had, and Angela did an amazing job scrutinizing the discovery and finding many flaws with the accusations. It was their hard work and dedication that eventually led to me being retained in the military. Mr. King was always professional and instilled confidence in me that I had nothing to fear. I would highly recommend his firm, knowing that his team will give you one hundred percent of their efforts and help you fight for what's right.
Adam WAdam W
00:27 10 Feb 24
Don and his team at King Military Law are truly incredible people. It's rare that you can call a law firm and speak directly with a lawyer, let alone someone like Don. He gave my father and I exactly the information we needed despite the challenges that ensued. It gave us hope in a very difficult time. Even afterwards, he's done everything he can to help me and my family take action and hopefully help many others in the process. Thank you Don 🙏
cforceman1cforceman1
19:16 09 Feb 24
I recently hired Don King and his team for my legal situation and they delivered expertly. I was not sure what my options were and they laid it out for me in a way I can understand. There are no guarantees when it comes to legal situations but I was lucky that I went with what I came to see was the best in the game. Give them a call. I wish you the same result that I had especially with Angela and Kasheta on the case too.
B MB M
21:58 24 Jan 24
Potentially found myself on the wrong side of an NJP that would have jeopardized my military career and discharge. This was not only a threat to my meticulously built reputation, but also to my future after military service. I was incredibly worried with no idea who to contact or trust.Here comes King's Law Firm - they are a dedicated and diligent team, filled with experienced professionals that have seen almost anything a service member can encounter. This is crucial - they have the unique perspective to provide comprehensive and informed legal advice. Upon listening to my situation, they instantly had a plan of action for me. This provided so much clarity and much needed relief.I cannot stress how beneficial the King Law Firm team has been to me. I need to shout out Ms. De La Garza - she actively listen to me for well over 20 minutes so that she could have the most accurate understanding of my situation. Her attentive nature tied with vast experience makes her such an invaluable asset to have on your side.I deeply appreciate the help, and will certainly use your firm in the future!
Lucas VazquezLucas Vazquez
01:43 11 Jan 24
If you're seeking legal assistance, King Military Law is where you need to go. I was going through legal issues with my command, Mr. King and his staff did above and beyond to help me. From making me feel comfortable and guiding me throughout the case. I can't thank them enough.
Christopher EsquivelChristopher Esquivel
03:25 05 Dec 23
Mr. King is very knowledgeable in military law. He was able to help me and made sure to explain everything in the most simple terms so that I can ensure I was in good hands. He is quick to help you address the issues you are going through and help you find solutions.
kyle doughertykyle dougherty
01:23 02 Nov 23
Don King and his practice, "King Military Law," have been an absolute game-changer in my life. From the moment I spoke to Don for a free consultation over a year ago, I knew I was making the right choice. The journey that followed has been nothing short of extraordinary.I had the opportunity to consult with several military lawyers, but it was Don's unwavering commitment and his word that won me over. He assured me he would stand by my side, and that promise has been upheld most remarkably. Don, along with his exceptional paralegals, Angela and Katesha, embarked on a tireless journey to fight for my rights and my future.The most significant battle they helped me win was against an administrative separation board. The dedication and diligence they put into my case were unparalleled. They left no stone unturned, meticulously examining every detail and aspect of my situation. Their level of commitment to my case was nothing short of inspiring.What truly sets Don King and his team apart is their exceptional communication. They consistently went above and beyond, ensuring I was informed at every stage. Their accessibility and willingness to answer any questions I had, no matter the time or day, gave me peace of mind during what could have been an extremely stressful period for my family and me.Don and his team didn't just treat my case as another file; they treated it as a number one priority. Their genuine care and concern for my well-being and the well-being of my witnesses were evident throughout our time together. They provided support and advocacy that goes above and beyond the call of duty.In conclusion, I couldn't be more thrilled with my experience with King Military Law. Don King and his exceptional team have met and exceeded my expectations in every way. If you need military legal representation, I wholeheartedly recommend Don King and his practice. They are not just legal professionals; they are compassionate allies who will fight relentlessly to ensure that justice prevails. Thank you, Don King and King Military Law, for giving me a second chance and being the unwavering support I needed during a challenging time. You are nothing short of amazing.
Cody WhortonCody Whorton
04:54 21 Oct 23
I am a Chief Petty Officer; I have served for our world’s finest Navy for 13 years. Unfortunately, I had a potential career ending legal event that threatened me with an administrative separation board. After calling numerous lawyers in San Diego, I called Mr. Don King and his legal team. Let me tell you, it was one of the best decisions that I have ever made. After speaking with Mr. King, I immediately felt that I had the best legal representation that I could possibly find. I WAS RIGHT! Don is the most honest, hard-working, and compassionate lawyer you are going to find! His team fought for me like I was their son. His team is super responsive and always helpful. They were very knowledgeable and were able to answer all my questions regarding the process. Don’s paralegal Angela would always ensure all required documentation was in order and received in a timely manner. She would even talk to me when I was feeling down and ensured I was making the right decisions on my part. Don fought at my board like it was the last day on earth. This is the best legal team in San Diego. If you choose only one lawyer, choose Mr. Don King and his legal team. YOU WILL NOT REGRET IT! Thank you, King family! My wife and I will never forget what you did to help us win this battle.
Scott PRESTIGIOCOMOScott PRESTIGIOCOMO
00:29 14 Oct 23
Had a conversation today with Mr king about a military court case 2000 miles away and spoke with over 20 other attorneys and not 5 of them combined gave me the amount of advice that he did himself! Very well educated in his field with a wealth of knowledge. I have multiple high end attorneys on retainer here in my state so I’m not foreign to well experienced attorneys and this man was what I am familiar with when it comes to well experienced. Sad that I had to swim thru a pool of uneducated attorneys whom claimed to be the best in their field only to find out that they had no clue to what seemed to myself and my legal/political friends to be a somewhat simple question for someone claiming to be a pro! This man is the real deal! This is not a paid or fake comment and I have never met this person who is very far from here and he helped me as if I was standing in front of him! Even as he was walking his dog he took his own time to get back to me. If you’re looking for a legit attorney then you’ve found him! I’d give more stars if possible. I’ll be telling my friends on the west coast in the area about you. Thank you for your time sir!
Jess SackettJess Sackett
20:19 15 Sep 23
Mr King recently defended my daughter for misconduct. His defense ended with a unanimous board decision clearing my daughter of that charge. Mr King was tenacious and unrelenting in her case. His staff are true professionals and highly skilled and experienced in preparing the cases. If you or someone you know needs a lawyer who will fight for you Mr King is the one you want in your corner.
js_loader

See All Reviews

Share This
× Overseas? Contact KML on WhatsApp